Keith Urban Is "Relieved" Nicole Kidman Moved On After Their Divorce — Wait, Wasn't He Just Devastated?!

Stop the presses, because the Keith Urban-Nicole Kidman post-divorce narrative just did a COMPLETE 180 — and honestly? We're getting whiplash.

The Plot Twist Nobody Saw Coming

According to Page Six, Keith Urban is reportedly "relieved" that his ex-wife Nicole Kidman has moved on with private equity investor Michael Reinstein. Yes, relieved.

But wait — didn't we JUST hear that the country star was "absolutely devastated" after seeing photos of Nicole cozying up to her new man in Italy? Because we definitely remember that report from earlier this week.

So which is it, Keith?

The Tea ☕

• Keith Urban, 58, is now reportedly "relieved" Nicole Kidman, 59, has moved on with businessman Michael Reinstein
• A new source claims Urban ended the marriage and felt "guilty" about hurting the Oscar winner
• BUT earlier this week, sources said he was "absolutely devastated" and secretly hoped for reconciliation
• The conflicting reports have everyone confused about what's ACTUALLY going on

He Felt Guilty, Apparently

Here's where it gets interesting. According to the Daily Mail (via Page Six), Keith was the one who wanted out of their nearly 20-year marriage. And apparently, he's been carrying some serious guilt about it.

"Keith was the one who wanted out of the marriage, and he felt guilty about hurting Nicole," an insider spilled to the outlet.

So now that Nicole's been spotted living her best life with Reinstein — lounging in the Italian sun, getting picked up from LAX in a Ferrari (yes, really) — Keith can supposedly breathe easier.

The source claims there's "no jealousy" over the new man, and Urban is just happy she's happy. How... mature?

But The Previous Story Was VERY Different

Here's the thing that's making our heads spin: This completely contradicts what we heard days ago.

Earlier this week, insiders were claiming Keith was "absolutely devastated" after seeing those Portofino photos. That source said the Grammy winner had been secretly hoping for a reconciliation and was crushed to see Nicole with another man.

So which version is true? Did someone's PR team suddenly kick into gear? Are there multiple sources with completely different takes? We need answers.

The Italy Photos That Started It All

Let's rewind to what sparked all this drama. Nicole and Michael Reinstein were photographed spending quality time together in Portofino, Italy in July. And these weren't just "casual friends grabbing coffee" vibes — we're talking lounging in the sun, deep conversations outside her hotel, the whole romantic getaway package.

Then came the Ferrari airport pickup in Los Angeles. VERY couple-y behavior, if you ask us.

Neither Nicole nor Reinstein has confirmed they're dating, but honestly? The photos are doing the talking.

Keith's Been Linked to Others Too

To be fair, Keith hasn't exactly been sitting at home crying into his guitar. Since the split, there have been romance rumors involving country singer Karley Scott Collins and his guitarist Maggie Baugh.

Both women denied being romantically involved with him, for what it's worth.

The Divorce Timeline

Nicole filed for divorce from Keith in September 2025 after 19 years of marriage, citing irreconcilable differences. Their divorce was finalized in January 2026.

The former couple shares daughters Sunday Rose, 18, and Faith Margaret, 15.

Our Take

Look, we're not saying someone's lying here. Maybe Keith really IS relieved Nicole's moved on. Maybe he WAS devastated at first and then processed his feelings. Maybe there are multiple sources who all have different perspectives on how he's handling this.

OR — and hear us out — maybe the truth is messier and more complicated than any single "source" can capture. Breakups are messy. Watching your ex of nearly 20 years date someone new? Even messier.

What we DO know is that both Keith and Nicole seem to be moving forward with their lives. Whether that's with relief, devastation, or some chaotic mix of both? Only they really know.

But we'll be watching for the next report that tells us he's actually thrilled or indifferent or whatever emotion comes next in this ever-changing narrative. 👀

Sources:

• Page Six: Keith Urban 'relieved' by Nicole Kidman's rumored new romance after he felt 'guilty' ending marriage: report

---

So what do you think — is Keith really relieved, or is this just damage control? And more importantly, are you Team Nicole or Team Keith in this post-divorce drama? Sound off below! 👇